How to dial life insurance leads to maximize contact rates

How to Dial Leads for 90% Contact Rates

August 18, 20267 min read

How to Dial Leads for 90% Contact Rates

Custom HTML/CSS/JavaScript

TOP PRODUCERS CONTACT RATE SOP

Fresh Lead & Aged Lead Dialing System

https://www.loom.com/share/c15a40669e6d4e349148faf44fa5f0f4


PURPOSE

This SOP is designed to help agents increase contact rates by following Jawad's exact process for fresh and aged leads.

The goal is simple:

More conversations → more presentations → more closes.


CORE PRINCIPLE

Most agents do not have a lead problem.

They have a contact problem.

And most contact problems come from:

  • Not dialing enough

  • Waiting too long between attempts

  • Being afraid of rejection

  • Not using multiple touchpoints

  • Giving up before the lead ever has a real chance to answer

This system works because it is built on volume, discipline, speed, and emotional detachment.


TARGET CONTACT RATE

Lead Type Target Contact Rate Fresh Leads 75%–95% Aged Leads 60%–90% Jawad's Example 30 contacted out of 32 leads = 93%


DAILY DIAL EXPECTATIONS

Agent Level Daily Dial Target New Agent 300–500 dials/day Experienced Agent 500–1,000 dials/day on aged leads Fresh Lead Agent 80–180 dials/day


FRESH LEAD SOP

Definition

A fresh lead is a lead that recently opted in.

Examples:

  • Meta lead

  • OTP verified lead

  • StrongPoint lead

  • Recently generated IUL or mortgage protection lead


FRESH LEAD PROCESS

Step Action Purpose 1 Call immediately Speed to lead matters 2 Double dial back-to-back Creates urgency and curiosity 3 Send a simple text Gives context and opens response 4 Wait 3–5 hours Do not burn fresh leads too fast 5 Double dial again in afternoon Second contact wave 6 Double dial again in evening Final first-day attempt 7 Move to local presence dialer if no answer Use different numbers to increase pickup


FRESH LEAD FIRST-DAY TOUCHPOINT TARGET

Time Block Action Morning 2 calls + 1 text Afternoon 2 calls Evening 2 calls Optional Additional text or voicemail

Total target: 6–9 touchpoints on Day 1.


FRESH LEAD TEXT TEMPLATE

Hey [Name], it's [Agent Name].

You had reached out after watching one of my videos about [IUL / mortgage protection / life insurance].

Looks like your main goal was [insert goal].

Were you more interested in:

  1. [Option A] or

  2. [Option B]?


IUL EXAMPLE TEXT

Hey Michael, it's (YOUR NAME).

You had reached out after watching one of my videos about the IUL.

Looks like your main goal was building tax-free wealth for retirement.

Were you more interested in a tax free retirement or leaving something behind for the family?


MORTGAGE PROTECTION EXAMPLE TEXT

Hey Sarah, it's Michael.

You had requested information about mortgage protection for the home.

Were you mainly looking to protect the mortgage if something happened to you, or were you more concerned about keeping the payment covered if you got ill or disabled?


FRESH LEAD DIALING SCHEDULE

Time Zone First Dial Block Eastern 8:30 AM Central 9:30 AM Eastern Pacific 11:30 AM Eastern


RECOMMENDED DAILY FRESH LEAD SCHEDULE

Time Action 8:30 AM–11:00 AM First fresh lead contact block 3:00 PM–5:00 PM Second contact block 6:00 PM–8:00 PM Evening contact block


AGED LEAD SOP

Definition

An aged lead is any lead that is no longer fresh.

Examples:

  • 7+ day old leads

  • Shared leads

  • Old Meta leads

  • Recycled CRM leads

  • Goat leads 😂

  • Old mortgage protection leads

  • Old IUL leads


AGED LEAD MINDSET

Do not call aged leads like they are old.

Call them like they just inquired today.

You never know if that same person recently became interested again.

The goal is to sort through the batch fast and find the people who are still curious, interested, or reachable.


AGED LEAD PROCESS

Step Action Purpose 1 Break leads into batches of 25 Keeps dialing organized 2 Triple dial each lead Creates maximum pickup opportunity 3 Finish entire batch Build rhythm and avoid overthinking 4 Restart same batch from the top Push each lead to 6 touches 5 Get each lead to 6–9 touches Find the reachable prospects 6 Move batch to local presence dialer Call from different numbers 7 Recycle later into aged lead pool Continue future dialing


AGED LEAD BATCHING METHOD

Batch Size Process 25 leads Dial each lead 3 times back-to-back Same 25 leads again Dial each lead 3 more times Optional third pass Push to 9 total dials if needed


AGED LEAD EXAMPLE

If you have 100 aged leads:

Batch Leads Batch 1 Leads 1–25 Batch 2 Leads 26–50 Batch 3 Leads 51–75 Batch 4 Leads 76–100

Work one batch at a time.

Do not jump around randomly.


AGED LEAD TOUCHPOINT TARGET

Pass Touchpoints First pass 3 dials Second pass 6 total dials Third pass 9 total dials

Target:

6–9 dials per lead within the first hour.


WHY THE AGED LEAD METHOD WORKS

This process helps you quickly identify:

  • Disconnected numbers

  • Wrong numbers

  • Angry prospects

  • Curious prospects

  • People who simply missed the first call

  • People who become curious after multiple calls

The goal is to get the bad leads out of the way and find the buyers faster.


CELL PHONE VS LOCAL PRESENCE DIALER

Tool When To Use Cell phone First contact attempt Cell phone Fresh lead first-day touches Cell phone Initial aged lead triple dials Local presence dialer After no answer from cell Local presence dialer When lead batch starts going dry Power dialer Aged leads or recycled leads


WHEN TO MOVE TO LOCAL PRESENCE

Move leads to local presence when:

  • They do not answer from your cell

  • The batch feels dry

  • You need a different number

  • You want to call multiple numbers at once

  • You have accumulated a recycled aged lead pool


ANGRY PROSPECT FRAMEWORK

A.R.P.

Step Meaning A Acknowledge R Respond P Pivot


ANGRY PROSPECT SCRIPT

Prospect:

"You called me 9 times!"

Agent:

Oh wow, looks like I may have accidentally butt-dialed you a few times there.

That's definitely on me.

But since I have you here real quick, it looks like you had requested information about [IUL / mortgage protection].

What was the bigger priority for you — [Option A] or [Option B]?


"I'M BUSY" SCRIPT

Prospect:

"I'm busy."

Agent:

I hear you.

This will only take about 2–3 minutes and then I'll get out of your way.

It looks like you had requested information about [mortgage protection / IUL / life insurance].

Were you mainly looking for [Option A] or [Option B]?


IMPORTANT LANGUAGE RULE

Do not say:

"I understand."

Say:

  • I hear you.

  • Totally fair.

  • Makes sense.

  • I got you.

Reason:

You do not actually understand their situation yet. "I hear you" acknowledges them without submitting to the objection.


COLOR-CODING TRACKER

Color Meaning Green Contacted Yellow Appointment set Blue Closed Orange Never contacted Red Dead / DNC Gray Wrong number / disconnected


TRACKING COLUMNS FOR GOOGLE SHEET

Column Header A Lead Name B Phone Number C Lead Type D Lead Source E Date Received F Time Zone G Dial Attempt 1 H Dial Attempt 2 I Dial Attempt 3 J Dial Attempt 4 K Dial Attempt 5 L Dial Attempt 6 M Dial Attempt 7 N Dial Attempt 8 O Dial Attempt 9 P Text Sent Q Contacted? R Appointment Set? S Presented? T Closed? U Status V Notes W Next Follow-Up


STATUS OPTIONS

Use these exact status labels:

  • New Lead

  • Double Dialed

  • Text Sent

  • Contacted

  • Appointment Set

  • No Show

  • Presented

  • Closed

  • Not Interested

  • Follow-Up

  • DNC

  • Wrong Number

  • Recycle


DAILY EXECUTION CHECKLIST

Task Complete Review new leads Sort leads by time zone Double dial all fresh leads Send first text Color-code status Run afternoon contact block Run evening contact block Move no-answers to local presence Recycle aged leads Update notes Track contact rate Track appointments set Track closes


CONTACT RATE FORMULA

Use this formula:

Contact Rate = Contacts ÷ Total Leads

Example:

30 contacts ÷ 32 leads = 93.75%


KEY PERFORMANCE INDICATORS

KPI Goal Fresh Lead Contact Rate 75%+ Elite Fresh Lead Contact Rate 90%+ Aged Lead Daily Dials 500+ Fresh Lead Daily Dials 80–180 First-Day Touches Per Fresh Lead 6–9 Aged Lead Touches First Hour 6–9 Presentations Per Day 3+ Policies Per Day 1–2+


TEAM RULES

  1. Do not complain about bad leads until you have properly worked them.

  2. A lead is not "bad" because they did not answer once.

  3. Fresh leads deserve 6–9 first-day touchpoints.

  4. Aged leads should be worked aggressively.

  5. Use cell phone first, then local presence.

  6. Track everything.

  7. Never emotionally react to rejection.

  8. Use A.R.P. on objections.

  9. Stay calm, direct, and assumptive.

  10. Your contact rate is usually a discipline issue before it is a lead issue.

life insurance dialing processlife insurance contact ratehow to work life insurance leads
blog author avatar

Michael Mauldin

Multi-million dollar producer. Sales trainer.

Back to Blog